If I were betting on the engines of future job creation, I wouldn’t put my money on college students cramming for tests and writing papers with properly formatted M.L.A.-style citations in order to bolster their résumés for careers in traditional professions and middle-management jobs in large corporate and government bureaucracies.
I’d put my money on the kids who are dropping out of college to start new businesses. If we want to get out of the jobs mess we’re in, we should hope that more will follow in their footsteps."
I think this article in the NY Times, entitled, "Will Dropout Save America?" by Michael Ellsberg (10/22/2011) commits the fallacy of Hasty Generalization. It is true that some dropouts have become incredible and successful pioneers (Jobs, Gates, Zuckerberg, ect.) However, basing an argument on the fact that college degrees are no longer effective and that we should rely on the populous of dropouts to save our economy is a sweeping generalization only justified by the few geniuses (specific cases) that actually knew what they were doing upon dropping out.
My essay is actually on success and how college correlates with success.I found that those who do attend college are in fact more successful in their lives. Of course there are exceptions because there are exceptions to everything in life, but college always came out on top in my research. A college degree gives you many more options than you have without a college degree. College also helps you broaden your horizons to be very cliche. All in all, there are many experiences and much knowledge that college students have and non- college students do not.
ReplyDeleteThe argument in itself is certainly a hasty generalization, covered up a bit by the authors rhetoric. Sounds a lot like a libertarian/anarchist argument against institutionalized education. This logic stems from a general consensus that a college education is a commodity, training rather than personal improvement.
ReplyDeleteI'm with Brian about the purpose of college -- economic advancement is at most a byproduct, not the point, and the arguer arguably misses this point. Another point he misses, in conflating business success with success generally, is that mercenary opportunism is not the same as being productive or good. Perhaps some of these famous dropouts had more to learn before they dropped out.
ReplyDeleteI see what you are saying and I agree. College in not a necessity in life, but it is a very beneficial luxury. Those who can afford to go to college and do not need to go out and get a job right away should definitely take advantage of the opportunity and go. I know that I sure am. I could have just gotten a job and made $10 per hour, but I would rather get an education and start with a salary of at least $40,000.
ReplyDelete